The third edition of the college football playoff rankings are out, and while not a lot has changed in the top 10, there's been some chaos between 11 and 25. As always, people are coming up with every argument they can think of for why things should be different and how the committee is being stupid. They overemphasize the arguments in their favor and ignore the rest.
But clearly, you're better than this because you clicked on this article. You want to know where you would rank everyone if all you had was the data and not the logos. You've come to the right place.
Just like the first two times, I'll give you three options. For casual fans who don't want to put a whole lot of time into this, I'll give you a 5-team test that includes BYU and four other teams of my choosing. For fans that are willing to spend more time, I'll give you a 15-team test that includes all the top 15 teams. And for those of you crazy fans like me, I'll give you a 26-team test that includes the top 25 plus one other team that I believe deserves more consideration. (This is the first time I've added the extra team. I figured there are 26 letters of the alphabet, so why not.)
For each test, I will randomly assign each team a letter. I'll give you a bunch of data about each team, but instead of telling you who each team is, I'll just give you the letter I assigned them. Your job is to rank each team only using the data I give you. Once you're done, then check the key at the end to see where you ended up ranking each team.
Allow me to explain the difference between the Higinbotham strength of schedule (my own model) and the FPI SOS (ESPN's model). The FPI SOS is a lot more advanced. However, it heavily favors the SEC and Big 10. Of the teams with the 19 strongest schedules according to FPI, 18 of them are from those two conferences.
My model, on the other hand, has more to do with how each team's opponents have actually played on the field. It's 50% your opponents' win percentage, 25% your opponents' opponents' win percentage, 12.5% your opponents' opponents' opponents' win percentage, and so on. This way, if a conference has a high nonconference win percentage, it will show up to a moderate degree in each team's SOS, but otherwise, there are no unfounded assumptions about which conferences are better.
I will point out that last week, there was a bug in my code that may have made the SOS only based on opponents' win percentage and didn't take it further like I intended. That bug is fixed now, so the rankings should be more reasonable than they were before. That being said, you still get to choose whether you trust my SOS rankings or ESPN's SOS rankings more.
Here are a couple pieces of advice. One, if you want your rankings to be truly unbiased, either only do one of the tests, or wait to check the key until you've done all of the ones you want do That way, you don't memorize your team's numbers and let that affect your rankings. And two, don't feel like you have to account for every column. If you don't think something should matter, don't pay attention to it. Just focus on what you think should matter.
Alright. Have at it.
5-team test:
Team | Record | Higinbotham SOS | FPI SOS | Average Scoring Margin | Ranked Wins | Ranked Losses | # of Unranked Losses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A | 9-1 | 38 | 68 | +13.7 | CFP 19, 20 | None | 1 |
B | 8-2 | 7 | 6 | +16.9 | CFP 16, 21 | CFP 1, 9 | 0 |
C | 9-1 | 41 | 53 | +23.6 | CFP 23 | CFP 7 | 0 |
D | 9-1 | 27 | 39 | +15.4 | CFP 18 | CFP 14 | 0 |
E | 8-2 | 6 | 31 | +7.3 | CFP 6, 19 | CFP 2 | 1 |
15-team test:
Team | Record | Higinbotham SOS | FPI SOS | Average Scoring Margin | Ranked Wins | Ranked Losses | # of Unranked Losses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A | 10-0 | 11 | 58 | +15.7 | Team L, CFP 19, 20 | None | 0 |
B | 9-1 | 8 | 25 | +23.4 | Team K, CFP 22, 24, 25 | None | 1 |
C | 8-2 | 2 | 2 | +12.4 | Teams I, O, CFP 25 | CFP 22, 24 | 0 |
D | 9-1 | 4 | 28 | +19.2 | Team J | Team M | 0 |
E | 8-2 | 93 | 40 | +11.8 | None | Team O | 1 |
F | 9-1 | 27 | 39 | +15.4 | CFP 18 | Team O | 0 |
G | 9-1 | 38 | 68 | +13.7 | CFP 19, 20 | None | 1 |
H | 7-3 | 1 | 12 | +5.3 | Team O, CFP 17, 18 | Team N | 2 |
I | 8-2 | 15 | 24 | +13.8 | Team K, CFP 16 | Team C, CFP 21 | 0 |
J | 9-1 | 41 | 53 | +23.6 | CFP 23 | Team D | 0 |
K | 8-2 | 7 | 6 | +16.9 | CFP 16, 21 | Teams B, I | 0 |
L | 8-2 | 6 | 31 | +7.3 | Team M, CFP 19 | Team A | 1 |
M | 9-1 | 52 | 42 | +25.7 | Team D | Team L | 0 |
N | 10-0 | 48 | 69 | +18.3 | Team H | None | 0 |
O | 7-3 | 16 | 10 | +16.5 | Teams E, F | Teams C, H, CFP 18 | 0 |
26-team test:
Team | Record | Higinbotham SOS | FPI SOS | Average Scoring Margin | Ranked Wins | Ranked Losses | # of Unranked Losses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A | 7-3 | 1 | 12 | +5.3 | Teams D, L, S | Team Q | 2 |
B | 6-4 | 3 | 3 | +0.2 | Teams F, O, T | Teams H, I, Z | 1 |
C | 9-1 | 4 | 28 | +19.2 | Team R | Team V | 0 |
D | 7-3 | 29 | 18 | +6 | Team L | Teams A, J | 1 |
E | 7-3 | 32 | 46 | +10 | None | Teams R, T | 1 |
F | 8-2 | 2 | 2 | +12.4 | Teams L, M, T | Teams B, H | 0 |
G | 7-3 | 14 | 45 | +5.1 | None | Teams K, X | 1 |
H | 6-4 | 20 | 7 | +3.3 | Teams B, F, T | Teams I, O, Z | 1 |
I | 9-1 | 8 | 25 | +23.4 | Teams B, H, T, W | None | 1 |
J | 9-1 | 27 | 39 | +15.4 | Team D | Team L | 0 |
K | 9-1 | 38 | 68 | +13.7 | Teams G, U | None | 1 |
L | 7-3 | 16 | 10 | +16.5 | Teams J, N | Teams A, D, F | 0 |
M | 8-2 | 15 | 24 | +13.8 | Teams O, W | Teams F, Z | 0 |
N | 8-2 | 93 | 40 | +11.8 | None | Team L | 1 |
O | 7-3 | 9 | 8 | -0.2 | Teams H, Z | Teams B, M, W | 0 |
P | 9-1 | 118 | 135 | +20.2 | None | None | 1 |
Q | 10-0 | 48 | 69 | +18.3 | Team A | None | 0 |
R | 9-1 | 41 | 53 | +23.6 | Team E | Team C | 0 |
S | 9-1 | 43 | 76 | +12.8 | None | Team A | 0 |
T | 6-4 | 19 | 1 | +6.3 | Team E | Teams B, F, H, I | 0 |
U | 7-3 | 63 | 44 | 11.1 | None | Teams K, X, Y | 0 |
V | 9-1 | 52 | 42 | 25.7 | Team C | Team Y | 0 |
W | 8-2 | 7 | 6 | 16.9 | Teams O, Z | Teams I, M | 0 |
X | 10-0 | 11 | 58 | +15.7 | Teams G, Y | None | 0 |
Y | 8-2 | 6 | 31 | +7.3 | Teams U, V | Team X | 1 |
Z | 6-4 | 31 | 21 | +4.1 | Teams B, H, M | Team W | 3 |
Here are the keys so you can see how you did:
5-team test:
Letter | Team | Current CFP ranking | Where I ranked them (out of these 5) |
|---|---|---|---|
A | Texas Tech | 12 | 3 |
B | Alabama | 3 | 2 |
C | Wake Forest | 11 | 5 |
D | Indiana | 8 | 4 |
E | BYU | 10 | 1 |
15-team test:
Letter | Team | Current CFP ranking | Where I ranked them |
|---|---|---|---|
A | Utah | 2 | 1 |
B | Georgia | 1 | 2 |
C | Texas | 5 | 5 |
D | Miami | 7 | 3 |
E | Iowa | 15 | 15 |
F | Indiana | 8 | 10 |
G | Texas Tech | 12 | 9 |
H | Oregon | 13 | 13 |
I | Tennessee | 9 | 7 |
J | Wake Forest | 11 | 12 |
K | Alabama | 3 | 8 |
L | BYU | 10 | 6 |
M | Notre Dame | 6 | 11 |
N | UCLA | 4 | 4 |
O | Ohio St | 14 | 14 |
26-team test:
Letter | Team | Current CFP ranking | Where I ranked them |
|---|---|---|---|
A | Oregon | 13 | 14 |
B | Florida | 24 | 21 |
C | Miami | 7 | 3 |
D | USC | 18 | 15 |
E | Louisville | 23 | 25 |
F | Texas | 5 | 5 |
G | Houston | 20 | 22 |
H | Oklahoma | 22 | 20 |
I | Georgia | 1 | 2 |
J | Indiana | 8 | 10 |
K | Texas Tech | 12 | 9 |
L | Ohio St | 14 | 16 |
M | Tennessee | 9 | 7 |
N | Iowa | 15 | 23 |
O | Kentucky | 16 | 17 |
P | Liberty | NR | 18 |
Q | UCLA | 4 | 4 |
R | Wake Forest | 11 | 12 |
S | Boise St | 17 | 13 |
T | Ole Miss | 25 | 24 |
U | Arizona | 19 | 26 |
V | Notre Dame | 6 | 11 |
W | Alabama | 3 | 8 |
X | Utah | 2 | 1 |
Y | BYU | 10 | 6 |
Z | South Carolina | 21 | 19 |
I will say, I did a much better job this time keeping my own rankings consistent across the three tests. There wasn't a single time that I ranked one team higher than another in one test and then swapped them in another. I've refined my method.
Here are my takeaways for this week:
1. BYU moved up. Last week, I had BYU ranked in roughly the same spot as the committee. This week, however, I moved them up to number 6. Was it because of their dominant win against Baylor? Actually no. It wasn't a ranked win, and I don't account for average scoring margin because I think your objective should be to win your games, not to make it look impressive. It had more to do with BYU's improved SOS, which was partly because they played a team with a solid record and partly because I fixed the error from last week.
Why is BYU's strength of schedule so good? Because with the exception of Colorado St, all of BYU's FBS opponents have a 500 record or better, and two of them are undefeated if you don't count their game against BYU. And most of BYU's opponents are Big 12 teams, who are mostly playing other Big 12 teams, and the Big 12 has the second best non-conference win record behind the SEC. So BYU definitely deserves more credit for their strength of schedule.
2. Overrated teams: Alabama, Notre Dame, Iowa, and Arizona. It is no secret that Alabama's ranking at number 3 is absurd. Any 2-loss team being number 3 is already questionable, and the fact that it's a team with no top 15 wins makes it even more ridiculous. Iowa's strength of schedule crumbles once you remove the Big 10 bias. I do feel bad for determining that both of the ranked teams BYU has beaten are overrated, but Arizona has no ranked wins, and while Notre Dame's win over Miami is very impressive, it's their only ranked win, and their schedule is very weak outside of BYU and Miami.
3. Underrated teams: Miami, Boise St, and Liberty. Miami may have only played two ranked teams and beaten one of them, but they still have one of the strongest schedules in the country because every FBS team they've played has at least 5 wins. Boise St also has a much stronger schedule than people are giving them credit for. As for Liberty, they may have a very weak strength of schedule, but they're 9-1. I can rank an 8-2 team higher than a 9-1 team if their resume is better. I can even rank a 7-3 team over a 9-1 team if their resume is better by a significant margin. But a 6-4 team should never be ranked higher than a 9-1 team.
Is the gap between the SEC and Conference USA big enough that a 6-4 SEC team is generally better than a 9-1 Conference USA team? Yeah, maybe. But that's only because the SEC has more resources and because none of the best recruits are going to want to go to a school where you get rewarded less for winning 90% of your games than other schools do for winning 60% of their games. If we want to create more equality in college sports, we have to err on the side of rewarding teams who are doing more with less.
4. Utah is number 1. You may think I'm the worst BYU fan ever for saying Utah should be number 1, but I have no reservations about it. They're one of only two undefeated teams in the country, they have by far the better resume of the two, and there aren't any 1-loss teams that have a resume so much better than Utah's that they deserve to be ranked higher despite Utah having the better record. Georgia may have four ranked wins, but three of them are against teams with 4 losses. Also, I want the Big 12 to get more credit and consideration, and if it's Utah that gets it for them, I'm more than OK with that. Besides, the better our rival is, the more fun it is to beat them.
As I always say at the end of every article, remember to be kind the officials.

