Skip to main content

Best and worst-case scenarios for BYU football's College Football Playoff chances

Hoping for the best but expecting the worst: the BYU football story.
ByCalvin Barrett
Nov 21, 2026; Lawrence, Kansas, USA; BYU Cougars quarterback Bear Bachmeier (47) throws a pass during the first half against the Kansas Jayhawks at David Booth Kansas Memorial Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jay Biggerstaff-Imagn Images
Nov 21, 2026; Lawrence, Kansas, USA; BYU Cougars quarterback Bear Bachmeier (47) throws a pass during the first half against the Kansas Jayhawks at David Booth Kansas Memorial Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jay Biggerstaff-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

BYU football is 9-2, currently ranked 10th in the nation (pending Tuesday's release of the College Football Playoff rankings), and coming off a narrow road win over the Kansas Jayhawks. And though it hasn't been the perfect season some expected from the veteran Cougars, it's been enough to keep them in the playoff picture.

But there remains one final regular season game to play for nearly every team in the nation, and though their current standing is favorable, Kalani Sitake's program is still far from a playoff lock.

The Cougars' chances of a spot in the College Football Playoff rely heavily on the following variables:

1. BYU's result vs. Cincinnati
2. Upsets higher in the rankings
3. Conference Championship auto-bids

Possible scenarios for BYU's CFP future, ranked worst to best

Instant Death: Lose to Cincinnati

The worst kind of death -- the instant kind.

Likely standing no higher than 9th in next week's CFP rankings, BYU loses to Cincinnati, kills any hopes of a conference championship rematch with Utah, and sends the Cougars to the Pop-Tarts Bowl -- an amazing worst-case scenario, but a conselation prize nonetheless.

Beating Cincinnati is the key. Lose, and there will be no bid for the 3-loss Cougars.

Notify Your Next of Kin: Bid-Stealer Bonanza

If the conference favorites above BYU lose in their respective championship games, those teams have a very strong case for an at-large bid, and the resulting automatic inclusions could then bump the Cougars out of the picture entirely.

These surprise champions become bid-stealers, and they're bubble teams' worst nightmares.

BYU finds themselves on the bubble, and if Texas Tech, Oregon, and Wake Forest all win their league's auto-bids, the Cougars could be teetering on the cliff of contention.

This scenario could toss BYU in the range of 11-13, giving them an uncomfortably narrow window to reach the CFP as an at-large bid. If they struggle against Cincinnati, that could be even more cause for concern from the selectors.

Hold Your Breath: Some Favorable Finishes

College Football Bracket Challenge

GET READY TO COMPETE

Pick your champion (you can change it later). We’ll email you when brackets open.

No purchase necessary. 50 U.S./D.C. 18+. Entry opens 3PM ET Dec 6, 2026 and closes 8PM ET Dec 18, 2026. Void where prohibited.See for complete details. The College Football Playoff (CFP) is not a sponsor or administrator of this contest.

BYU can likewise climb into the Playoff with some help from the teams ahead of them.

Miami beats Wake Forest in the ACC title game. Utah handles Texas Tech. Any team in the 6-9 range loses in their final regular-season game.

Here's the boulder I think has begun to roll down the hill: UCLA, fresh off a humiliating defeat at Michigan, loses against a ranked USC team in their final regular game, potentially spitting the Bruins out of the CFP entirely.

Just as BYU should vault Indiana after the Hoosiers' loss to Washington, they could benefit by simply winning the game in front of them, and letting the cards fall where they may.

Cautious Optimism: In the Hands of the Committee

I know how ridiculous it sounds, but I have to say it: the selection committee has sort of been BYU's best friend this season.

After back-to-back seasons of getting snubbed, BYU hasn't been a very big fan of the committee's tendencies and SEC-leaning tendencies. In the first two years of the 12-team playoff, the Big 12 Conference has received zero at-large nods. This year, however, the Cougars are in the playoff picture despite a bad loss at UCF and another loss to rival Utah.

Even as the AP Poll and non-CFP affiliates consistently ding BYU for their shortcomings, their marquee victory consistently places the Cougars above other bubble teams like Wake Forest, Texas Tech, and Oregon in the only ranking that matters.

The win against Notre Dame has been critical. Thanks especially to the Irish's massive win over Miami, Notre Dame's reputation as a national championship contender only lifts the Cougars as high as the Irish can climb. And though they likely won't surpass Notre Dame in the rankings, BYU can ride that win directly into the bracket.

So let's imagine the final weeks of the season play out in a mostly uneventful fashion. Georgia, Utah, UCLA, and Miami win their respective leagues, and BYU sits out the Big 12 championship game. It's hard to imagine the Cougars plummet with that win over ND serving as their ticket through the gates.

Rejoice: An Auto-bid Dream Scenario

Here's the scene: Texas Tech stumbles at the finish line against TCU, and BYU's tiebreaker grants the Cougars a second shot at Utah.

In Sitake's second consecutive annual trip to Arlington, the Cougars even the score against Morgan Scalley's red-hot Utes, taking home the Big 12 championship and claiming the Big 12's automatic bid to the College Football Playoff.

This is the only sure path to the postseason tournament for BYU, though it's also the most challenging. Facing Utah in the CCG is a major risk, and one that could kill the Cougars' chances for the second straight season if they lose.

But if they win, that's a moot point.

Add us as a preferred source on Google