For the first time in a long time, BYU football posted a complete effort. Taking down Baylor won't impress the casual viewer, as the Bears fall to 6-4 and appear to be on their way toward a final 6-6 regular season record, but this was a team that had the Cougars on upset watch and could have been the final barrier between themselves and a program-first CFP bid.
But the Cougars weren't afraid of one of football's best defenses, nor did Kelly Poppinga's defense flinch at DJ Lagway and Baylor's red-hot offense. Instead, the Cougars jumped out to a 21-0 lead, controlled the clock, and finished strong with a 28-7 final.
This is a win that BYU needed badly, not only in terms of opponent strength, but in overall quality. This was BYU football as we saw it in the first six games of the season -- the team the Cougars need to be to acheive their postseason goals.
First half was BYU's most complete of the season
The Cougars controlled possession, controlled the clock, and enforced their will on a Baylor team that had played amazing football in their previous two games.
Baylor's first possession turned 3-and-out, and BYU's ensuing possession ran 9 plays long, burning four minutes off the game clock.
After another quick stop, BYU drove 86 yards on 12 plays, shaving another 6 minutes off the clock.
Their next possession? 18 plays. 96 yards. 9 minutes.
The Cougars scored a touchdown on all three of their first three possessions, holding a previously scorching Baylor team to 0 points in the first half. They ran the ball with authority, opening up the passing game as they got back to what this team has been known for.
They ran for 189 yards on the night compared to 123 yards through the air. 47 rushing attempts is a great sign for BYU, a team better-equipped to control the game while ahead than to catch up from a deficit.
BYU's defense is back (held Baylor to 7 points despite recent hot streak and great QB)
It's been a bad month or so for the BYU defense that opened the year with minimal dip in production from Jay Hill's departure to Ann Arbor. But since defeating Notre Dame, BYU's defense was a conglomeration of missed tackles, coverage breakdowns, and open doors on 3rd down.
DJ Lagway and the Baylor Bears scored 41 points or more in each of their last two games, but were held to just 7 in LaVell Edwards Stadium.
While the awkward layover situation may have played a factor, there's no denying that BYU was the better team from start to finish in this one. Defense and the running game have been the driving factors for every Bear Bachmeier-led BYU team -- the defense is back to business at a critical point in the season.
Second-half Cougars are horribly boring
BYU football is a very boring team when they have the lead in the second half.
They gave up a 14-0 third quarter against Arizona State, allowing a staggering Sun Devils team to tie the score
They went scoreless against Utah after opening the half with a 20-14 lead.
If you think you’ve seen unwatchable football you’ve never seen BYU with a 3 score lead
— Joe Wheat (@joewheat27) November 15, 2026
BYU also went scoreless in the third quarter of this game, opting to drain the game clock rather than keep their foot on the accelerator, it goes well beyond Kalani Sitake's discomfort with blowing an opponent out. It's by design.
When you have an offensive line as strong as the Cougars', a potent rushing game can effectively keep the game out of reach.
It's effective. It's a winning strategy. But it's not exciting football. Wins above everything, of course, but no one would blame you if you switched the channel over to a more high-octane matchup midway through the third quarter.

