The third edition of this year's College Football Playoff rankings has been released, and from behind their closed door, the selection committee has granted the BYU Cougars the 10th overall position.
BREAKING: College Football Playoff Ranking🚨https://t.co/MHjz4nNP7G pic.twitter.com/cGKU4UoZ0I
— On3 (@On3) November 18, 2026
Obviously, there are a lot of things that make no logical sense in this release. Alabama is far, far too high without any impressive wins outside of an inflated Kentucky team. The SEC is backloading the rankings with four 6-4 teams in the 21-25 range, the only reason being to boost the resumes of the SEC as a whole. An unbeated Big Ten team is only ranked 4 because of the name on their helmet.
But as far as BYU is concerned, 10th is a gift.
That means if the playoff were to begin today, the Cougars would be in the field as an at-large bid. What a wild thought, considering how last year's team was locked out of the bracket due to two top-10 losses. We cried, we screamed, and in outrage we fought the committee's final ruling with all our might. In the end, the only opinion that matters is the one of those in power.
It's just wild that those in power are tipping the cap to an 8-2 BYU team.
BYU's current standing not only indicates they're heading toward a CFP berth, but that they have a little bit of wiggle room, assuming they don't reach the Big 12 title game. In fact, not playing in Arlington in a rematch against Utah only helps the Cougars' chances of reaching the playoff, unless some bid-stealing melarchy pulls the rug out from under Kalani's crew.
Wake Forest lurks at 11. Tech could leapfrog the Cougars if they win the Big 12 championship game (though BYU owns the tiebreaker if the Red Raiders slip in the next two weeks). Oregon and Ohio State's name value could fling them into the final bracket if they remain this close.
But BYU is in right now. And a 10-2 season should -- in theory -- be good enough to grant them access to the postseason tournament.
But in order to project their future, we have to understand the events that got us here. Why is BYU ranked in the top 10 after two losses, and what does it mean for their CFP hopes?

Hypotheses to explain BYU's position in latest CFP rankings
Hypothesis #1: BYU has an excellent resume
This is the most likely rationale, though one that isn't perfectly consistent with the committee's tendencies over the years.
To BYU's credit, they have a pillar of a win over (6) Notre Dame. That 28-24 final is holding the Cougars' resume together, like Tom Holland's Spider-Man did to that boat in Homecoming. A marquee win was the factor missing from BYU's resume last season, despite wins over 10-2 Utah, 9-3 Arizona, and a handful of other reasonable Big 12 competition.
This year, they're the only team that has beaten a playoff-bound Notre Dame -- not even (7) Miami holds that designation.
BYU also has a one-possession loss to (2) Utah on the road, though the committee didn't fault the Cougars for a narrow defeat against a titan. It's the loss to UCF that dangles this team's heels over the cliff; that double-overtime disaster.
Had the Cougars simply handled business in Orlando, it would be smooth sailing to the postseason. But they didn't. Graciously, BYU is far from the only team to have a baffling loss on their resume, and the committee is in a particularly forgiving mood this year.
Hypothesis #2: The Big 12 is suddenly respected nationally
Hahahahaha. No, probably not.
Though it's worth mentioning that this year gives the Big 12 a serious chance for not just one, but two at-large teams to join the party. It would be the first time the Big 12 Conference (powered by Monster Energy) gets an at-large bid, and could set off a chain reaction toward a brighter, more respected future for the league.
Hypothesis #3: This is the committee's apology
BYU is one of the winningest teams in college football over the last three years. At 31-6, Kalani Sitake's program has been in the CFP conversation for each of those seasons, narrowly missing out every time.
And for reasons I've already explained and don't care to reiterate, last year's team was unequivocally robbed of a chance to participate.
But this year, BYU started hot, ranked in the top 15 of the AP Poll in every week, and in the top 10 of every CFP ranking.
It could be experience, continuity, or that remarkable win over Notre Dame, but most of all, the committee might just decide that it's BYU's turn to have a swing. Probably not. Imagining the selection committee giving BYU football the benefit of the doubt is borderline impossible, yet here we are. You explain it.

