Welcome to Too Optimistic Tuesday! This weekly column reminds BYU fans why they should count their many blessings and have an abundance of hope.
Every season in every sport is full of both ups and downs. This column will amplify the "ups" and help fans quickly recover from the "downs". So put on your blue-tinted goggles and just indulge me in some hyperbole while enjoying your BYU fandom for a moment.
Kelly Poppinga's defense is legit
While the Baylor Bears had to reenact Planes, Trains, and Automobiles to get to Provo, they ultimately arrived in the Beehive State with one of the Big 12's most potent offenses in tow. At 4-2 in conference play, the Bears harbored their own desires to still reach the Big 12 championship game, and they seemed to be peaking at the right time.
In its last two games leading up to their trip to Provo, Baylor had scored 83 points in dominant wins over UCF (41-9) and Iowa State (42-31).
Just let that stat wash over you for a moment before we proceed:
Baylor was coming off back-to-back conference wins while scoring over 40 points in both games.
But all of that offensive momentum came to a screeching halt against Kelly Poppinga's dominant defense. Behind an impeccable game plan, BYU's defense came out with its hair on fire. They quickly let Baylor know they were about to get punched in the mouth with an electric Bodie Schoonover sack on the game's first possession.
Bode Schoonover with a monster sack for BYU to wreck Baylor’s first drive! pic.twitter.com/MsH0v6DE3n
— Diggin’ Brigham (@DigginBrigham) November 15, 2026
Baylor's first half offensive possessions went punt, punt, punt, punt, end of half.
The Bears opened the second half with two third quarter possessions that ended with a punt and an awesome Tommy Prassas interception.
Even as BYU's offense "turtled" throughout most of the second half, those first six dominant defensive possessions by the Cougars' defense was all that was needed to put the game away. By the end of the game BYU had three sacks while Baylor averaged a ho-hum 3.4 yards per carry and quarterback DJ Lagway had to attempt 37 passes to generate 159 yards.
Kudos to K-Pop and all of the dawgs on BYU's defense.
What this means for the College Football Playoffs
Provided BYU handles its business in its last two games to finish 10-2, the No. 10 Cougars should be firmly in the College Football Playoffs. And if the Cougars' defense continues playing at the level it showed against Baylor, Kalani Sitake's squad can beat any team in the country. I watch a lot of college football and among the other Top 12 teams, there's a lot of shaky quarterback play.
When BYU's defense is "on", it can rattle any quarterback in the country.
Take, for instance, what BYU did to currently-ranked No. 5 Notre Dame. The Cougars held an electric Irish offense to 24 points.

In three Power Four games before coming to Provo, Notre Dame had scored 49, 37, and 58 points, respectively.
After losing 28-24 to BYU, Notre Dame has since scored 35, 31, and 41 points. Notre Dame's offense has been a juggernaut this year, except for the week they faced off against Kelly Poppinga's unit.
If BYU's defense can get a few key players healthy like Isaiah Glasker and Evan Johnson, they can hang with any team in the CFP. They've done it with Notre Dame. They showed out against Baylor.
BYU's defense is playing so well right now that this column could be re-titled "Too Realistic Tuesday" instead of "Too Optimistic Tuesday" in looking forward to a potential Cougars' postseason run.

